The Earthspinner by Anuradha Roy

First published in the UK in 2021; published by HarperVia on July 5, 2022

The Earthspinner is in part a story of forbidden love. More fundamentally, it is a story of creative obsession and prejudice against art that crosses implied boundaries. Elango is a potter, carrying on the tradition of his caste. To make ends meet, he also drives an autorickshaw. His favorite passenger is Zohra, a girl who walks with a limp. Elango falls in love with Zohra but “they belong to tribes that hated each other and he knew they could never be together.” Elango “could not utter what she was, a Muslim. The space between the two was a charnel house of burnt and bloodied human flesh, a giant crack through the earth that was like an open mouth waiting to swallow him.”

Elango dreams of an earthen horse and comes to believe that if he shapes the horse from clay, Zohra will be his. The novel follows Elango as he devotes his free time to creating the horse of his dreams. Zohra’s grandfather, a blind calligrapher, carves into the horse a beautiful poem about riding the freedom of imagination. But Anuradha Roy wants the reader to understand that freedom in India only lives in the imagination. Elango is not free to marry Zohra. Nor is he free to express himself with a horse that does not suit the arbiters of his religion.

Elango’s grandfather once made horses for temples. People who see the horse believe a temple is where it belongs. They do not realize that the poem decorating the horse is written in Urdu, “the language of mullahs,” a desecration of a temple horse — at least in the view of Hindu temple priests.

Elango’s story is narrated by Sara, whose mother is a journalist. As a young girl, Sara learned the craft of pottery from Elango — to the chagrin of neighbors who thought she had no business learning such things.

The story begins and ends in the present. Five years have passed since Elango’s story ended. Everything has changed; the villagers have made new lives; the village has melted into the earth, taking with it the memories of the horrific event that is the novel’s defining moment. Sara remembers her father telling her that “change was the work of the earth spinning, spinning as it always had.”

Sara is studying English literature in England and making pots to relieve her stress. She notes the difference between rural India, where neighbors are nosy, and England, where “curiosity is bad manners.” One of Sara’s friends is experiencing, like Elango, a form of love that is forbidden by her culture.

The collegiate Sara catches up with Elango and becomes an audience to whom he can unburden himself, “a girl who shared his language as well as momentous bits of his past.” She decides to tell his story. Sara emphasizes how he has changed, how life has taken him on an unexpected path. She also assesses how she has changed, solidifying change as one of the novel’s themes, embodied in Sara’s understanding that the cosmos is “hell-bent on doing things we can neither anticipate nor prevent.”

A dog is central to the story, adding further evidence to my conviction that every work of fiction is improved by the addition of a dog. The dog is lost when its owners suffer a carjacking. Elango adopts the dog and it becomes beloved by the village. The dog creates tension for a character who knows that its former owners are searching for him, but the character is convinced that the dog is happy and should not be uprooted again. Uprooting and rebirth are among the novel’s themes. Sara explains that where she comes from, “we have always known that ordinary days can explode without warning, leaving us broken, collecting the scattered pieces of our lives, no clear idea how to start again.”

Religious fanaticism is the story’s darkest theme. Yet Roy makes clear that religion is not necessarily to blame for the fanatics that turn religion into a vehicle for hate. Sara’s father helps her realize that the war between Hindu and Muslim is not about religion at all, but it more like the blood feud that underlies Romeo and Juliet. The story’s most hopeful theme is the possibility of repair and restoration, of fixing what’s broken or learning that we don’t need the broken thing after all.

The Earthspinner might be viewed as an allegory of the teacher and student. It might be viewed as a love story or the story of a young woman’s unrequited (and perhaps unrecognized) love. It might be viewed as an indictment of prejudice in India and the larger world. It might be viewed as a commentary on the challenges and costs of artistic creation. It might be viewed as a reflection on tests of character, how we pass or fail them or fail to recognize them. The Earthspinner is a deceptively simple novel that works on many levels, giving the reader a trove of possibilities to unpack. Like all of Roy’s work, The Earthspinner is worthy of a careful unpacking.

RECOMMENDED

After the Lights Go Out by John Vercher

Published by Soho Press on June 7, 2022

Xavier’s father is suffering from dementia. Xavier and his mother are black. Xavier never suspected his white father of racism, but he’s starting to understand that his father made racist comments to his mother while watching rioting after the Rodney King verdict. As a child who worshipped his father, Xavier did not understand that his father’s emerging racism prompted his mother’s decision to leave.

Xavier is a professional cage fighter. He’s long been on the verge of moving up the ranks and making real money, but never quite reached that level. Coming off a one-year suspension for steroids, it looks like he never will. He’s taken so many blows to the head that he’s suffering from headaches, blackouts, memory lapses, and moments of uncontrollable rage. He fears he will become his father, out of touch with reality. When a nurse asks Xavier if he sees his future in his father, Xavier replies “It’s like looking in a mirror with the lights off.”

Xavier works for his cousin, a manager and fight trainer who goes by Shot. Shot lost his eye and his fighting career to a police beating. Xavier is in the doghouse with Shot after losing control and nearly beating the life out of one of Shot’s fighters while sparring. Shot is taking money from the mob and Xavier’s rage has made Shot’s life difficult.

While Xavier is an MMA fighter, the plot is standard for a boxing novel. The fighter is instructed to take a dive. The mob will take revenge if he doesn’t. Will he or won’t he? The novel departs from the formula by focusing on Xavier’s brain damage. Whether Xavier will even remember that he’s supposed to take a dive is the question that gives the novel its tension.

The main plot is secondary to the subplots that construct Xavier’s character. Xavier must reinterpret his relationship with his father now that he understands his father’s racism. Xavier is conflicted about whether to keep his father in his house or in an assisted-living facility. Xavier has unresolved issues with his mother that the story gives him a chance to resolve. Xavier’s relationship with a dog is heartbreaking, as is the betrayal of a brain that has taken too many knocks. Xavier is a gentle beast at heart, but his damaged brain is increasingly losing its violence barriers, impairing his ability to recognize the person he is becoming.

John Vercher’s prose moves with the swiftness and certainty of a skilled fighter. He gives the story a feeling of authenticity by detailing Xavier’s struggle to sweat out 10 pounds before his big fight. The only choice Vercher made that doesn’t work is an internal voice, words spoken in a bold font, perhaps the devil’s voice, that speaks to Xavier from time to time, representing the dark side of human nature. The voice that tells Xavier not to care about anyone but himself. Maybe blows to the head make fighters hear voices, but the contrivance is an unnecessary distraction.

Still, All the Lights Go Out tells a powerful story. Like Xavier, it pulls no punches. The plot contains no surprises, the ending seems inevitable, but the story ends as it should. The juxtaposition of a character in the grip of dementia and a son who is becoming his father gives the story more depth than a typical novel of its kind.

RECOMMENDED

Planes by Peter C. Baker

Published by Knopf on May 31, 2022

Planes begins by inserting the reader in the head of an Italian woman who changed her name from Maria to Amira when she converted to Islam after marrying Ayoub. Amira did not convert because she has any strong religious belief but because she thought supporting Ayoub’s religion would give him stability and strengthen their marriage.

In the opening pages, we learn that Amira is living alone. She is saying at least some of her daily prayers to feel closer to her husband. Ayoub has been detained without charges for two years, presumably on suspicion of terrorism. His lawyer believes he’s being held in a prison in Morocco, but his heavily censored and irregularly delivered letters reveal little about his life.

The first section of the novel reveals Amira’s fear that everyone in her neighborhood is judging her for being married to a terrorist. She is also afraid to be seen with a friend from her childhood, the boy who took her virginity and who has resurfaced in Rome. Amira is scraping by, using all her earnings to pay rent to maintain their apartment in the hope that Ayoub will return, allowing them to resume their life together in a familiar environment.

The novel then begins a journey through the lives of connected characters — the kind of characters who dominate mainstream American fiction. Melanie is liberal who serves on a school board in Springwater, North Carolina. The long-term best friends of Melanie and her husband Art bonded years ago over their commitment to social activism, but now their friendship seems like a habit. Melanie is tasked with making a compromise with Bradley Welk, a Republican member of the school board, so naturally they end up negotiating in bed. The affair becomes complicated. That’s the nature of affairs.

When the story circles back to Amira, we get Ayoub’s backstory. He is working in a pizza shop when Amira first meets him. She is bored and looking for a “symbol of difference. A new thing. A discovery. Foreign.” The story follows their marriage and the developments that strain it, beginning with all the people who tell her it is wrong to marry a Pakistani or any Muslim. Their story eventually returns to the present.

How are the stories linked? The plane that transported Ayoub from Italy to the secret prison in Morocco took off from Springwater, using a local air charter service that is a CIA front. Local residents were in the dark about the charter service, except perhaps for Welk, who is listed as one of its owners. It’s bad enough to have an affair but having an affair with someone who enables torture is particularly rough for a liberal, compounding Melanie’s anxiety about her selfish choice.

The best scenes in the novel involve Ayoub’s attachment to a stray cat — a cat that, like Ayoub, survives deep wounds and needs to be healed, a cat that brings back memories of a cat who served as a symbol of love in a place of darkness — and Amira’s resentment that Ayoub does not display the same attachment to her.

Planes benefits from Peter Baker’s fluid prose and careful exploration of how a false accusation of terrorism devastates lives. The Springfield characters are also built with solid characterization, but their story is familiar and less interesting. My knock on the novel is Baker’s complete failure to resolve any of its storylines. That’s a trend in modern novels, a reflection of the reality that each moment in life is a shapshot in time and who knows what might happen next? The high school teachers who told us that stories should have a beginning, a middle, and an end turned out to be wrong, at least to modern novelists who see no need to work out endings. Still, it’s frustrating not to have at least a partial resolution of at least one storyline. Characterization and fluid prose earn Planes a recommendation, but the novel isn’t for readers want to know what happens next.

RECOMMENDED

Monkey in the Middle by Loren D. Estleman

Published by Forge Books on June 21, 2022

Hardboiled private detectives have always been a mainstay of crime fiction. They no longer dominate the field, but there are still a few fictional private eyes who are worth following. Loren D. Estleman’s long-running Amos Walker series is near the top of my list of current private eye stories that are worth a reader’s time.

Shane Southern is a researcher who worked for a successful but recently retired writer. Shane hires Amos under a pretext. Amos has a nose for pretext and, after accepting Shane’s retainer, follows him to learn what the man is really about. His investigation leads him to Abelia Hunt, a fugitive who stole some government secrets that the government wants back. The monkey in the middle is the one that hears no evil. The government does not want its secrets to be heard.

When a DIA agent searching for Abelia turns up dead, Amos has a murder mystery on his hands. The DIA agent’s partner, Abelia’s lawyer, a journalist, and a retired cop all play significant roles in the plot as Amos pieces the clues together.

A secondary plot begins with the death of Amos’ ex-wife. She died of cancer, but the man with whom she was living tells Amos that a blue Buick was following her in the last weeks of her life. Readers who understand how crime novels are constructed will suspect that there is a link between the surveillance of Amos’ former wife and the surveillance of Shane (and eventually Amos) by agents who are trying to find Abelia.

With its history of corruption and a pronounced gap between wealth and squalor, Detroit is a natural setting for a crime novel. An abandoned gas station that was once a thriving front for a criminal organization is the kind of landmark that adds the color of noir to Amos’ tale.

Estleman is a reliable storyteller who writes with flair. Amos’ office is decorated in “tasteful earth tones of dirty olive and oil spill.” Estleman’s evocative prose, his smart plot, and his atmospheric setting make Monkey in the Middle a good choice for fans of traditional private detective stories.

RECOMMENDED

The Local by Joey Hartstone

Published by Doubleday on June 14, 2022

The Local is a courtroom drama that stars a patent lawyer. Patent law offers little drama to anyone other than inventors who believe their inventions have been stolen. Since patent infringement trials are snoozeworthy, fans of courtroom dramas will be pleased to learn that patent disputes give way to a murder trial early in the novel.

James Euchre has a patent law practice in the Eastern District of Texas. Judge Gardner has earned a reputation that makes him favored by lawyers who want to file patent infringement lawsuits. Big firms from all around the country file suits in Marshall, Texas and some of them hire Euchre as their local counsel. Euchre often delivers the closing statement because jurors relate to him. He also gets along well with Gardner. The judge has been Euchre’s mentor.

Euchre is hired as local counsel to represent an American of Pakistani ancestry. The client, Amir Zawar, has a negative experience with Gardner at their first court appearance. Zawar scuffles with Euchre (who is trying to stop Zawar from confronting the judge) and says “I’ll kill you,” perhaps to the Marshal who is twisting his arm but perhaps to the judge. In any event, someone murders the judge in the courthouse parking lot and circumstantial evidence points the finger of guilt at Zawar.

Euchre ends up agreeing to represent Zawar in a state murder prosecution. It seems like terrible judgment for a patent lawyer to take on a murder prosecution as his first criminal case, but that’s the premise so the reader needs to roll with it to enjoy the story. I understand Zawar’s desire to be represented by local talent, but one wonders why he didn’t ask about local lawyers who might be familiar with criminal law. Euchre is at least second chaired by a patent lawyer who used to be a federal prosecutor.

Most of the novel is devoted to trial theater. Euchre develops a couple of alternative suspects, including a Magistrate who benefits from Gardner’s death by gaining a nomination to replace him on the bench. In the tradition of courtroom dramas, the reader wonders who actually committed the murder. The reveal is surprising and tolerably credible, making the novel a success from the perspective of plot development, which is generally the most important element of a courtroom drama. There’s also enough action at the end to justify classifying the novel as a thriller. To his credit, Joey Hartstone underplays the action. Euchre might have played cornerback in high school, but patent lawyers aren’t credible action heroes.

Some of the novel’s characterization is based on Euchre’s connection to Marshall, the town where he grew up and where he played high school football (on a team that was a rival of the prosecutor’s). That works because it’s Texas, where high school football reigns supreme. Euchre lives in the shadow of his father, a successful criminal defense lawyer. Euchre’s guilt about his relationship with his bipoplar dead wife is a bit forced but it isn’t overplayed. Hartstone gives Euchre the psychological burdens that make characters interesting. A female private detective who used to be a star high school field goal kicker is a bit sassy, making her the best collateral character.

At times, Euchre becomes philosophical. The novel’s interest comes from the plot, not from Euchre’s musings about life. Still, the plot is sufficiently strong to make The Local a novel that fans of courtroom thrillers should enjoy.

RECOMMENDED